meta_pixel
Tapesearch Logo
Catholic Answers Live

#12140 How Should We Theologically Understand Neanderthals? - Jimmy Akin

Catholic Answers Live

Catholic Answers

Religion & Spirituality, Christianity

4.82.1K Ratings

🗓️ 5 April 2025

⏱️ 55 minutes

🧾️ Download transcript

Summary

With evidence of burial rituals and culture, were Neanderthals spiritual beings like us? We explore their place in theology, along with topics like praying in dreams, moral behavior in animals, the nature of heaven, and whether we could ever learn like computers.

Join The CA Live Club Newsletter: Click Here

Questions Covered:

  • 01:13 – What physical explanation can parapsychology offer? Because one thing is describing phenomena, another one is explaining it in a physical framework. 
  • 11:15 – How are we to consider our Neanderthal cousins? They were hominids, close enough to us that we interbred (I have more than the average Neanderthal DNA), they had a culture, and there is evidence that they not only buried their dead, but buried flowers and grave goods with them, hinting at a belief in the afterlife. Yet, they were different from us, and they went extinct millennia before the Incarnation. Theologically, how are they considered? semi-Neanderthal minds want to know! 
  • 16:31 – Can animals act in ways that are morally good or evil? i.e. the dog that saves the child vs the dog that bites the child. What implications, if any, would that have on the prospect of an animal afterlife? 
  • 22:44 – If I am asleep and I dream that I am praying, is it possible that God and the saints I ask for intercession hear those prayers? And if I receive a blessing in the context of my dream, is it possible that some minor intercession has occurred? 
  • 29:15 – If a sincere penitent in the confessional confesses that he has set a bear trap outside the priest’s confessional, set to go off the moment the priest exits the confessional, could the priest require the penitent to remove the bear trap as a part of his penance? Or can the priest not make requirements like that in order to give absolution? (One that I’ve actually gotten from my students!) 
  • 34:34 – Tell us about your Arkansas accent. It’s coming on pretty thick these days. I assume you lost it when you moved to CA and now that your back you just naturally fell back into it? 
  • 41:30 – I’ve never heard anyone address this: after the resurrection, we will be reunited with our physical bodies. So is heaven a physical place? 
  • 44:15 – Growing up I was told that our souls wander about while we sleep as an explanation for Deja vu. I know in the past you’ve attributed Deja vu to remote viewing, how similar are these 2 ideas? 
  • 52:45 – The mystery of learning and memory. Why can’t humans learn, store, and recall information in the same way a computer does (i.e. massive storage, data compressibility/extractability, can download and upload information, etc.)? It would seem extremely beneficial if humans could learn via download and share via upload like computers. Just to qualify I mean the speed of data transfer as well. For example, instead of spending years learning a new language, just download it and have perfect fluency (similar to the Matrix and how Neo could learn things). 

Transcript

Click on a timestamp to play from that location

0:00.0

Buying or selling your home, real estate for life can connect you with a pro-life real estate agent.

0:05.8

When Real Estate for Life receives a referral fee, they donate 65% to Catholic Answers.

0:11.5

Learn more at realestateforlife.org. Welcome back to Catholic Answers Live.

0:33.9

That lovely music, and I really do love that music, is also the indicator that we're going to have some fun.

0:40.6

Whenever we hear that music, that means we're going to do weird questions with Jimmy Aiken.

0:43.7

Jimmy Aiken, our guest, Jimmy, of course, senior apologist here at Catholic Answers and the proprietor of Jimmy Aiken's Mysterious World and the Jimmy Aiken podcast and also keeping a whole bunch of other Catholic podcasters in business,

0:57.0

author of many books, and willing to take any question quite seriously and do his very best to give you an answer.

1:04.4

Thank you for coming back for another hour, Jimmy Aiken.

1:07.1

Yeah, no problem.

1:09.7

All right, well, let's go right back to the questions.

1:11.9

This one comes from Giuliano.

1:14.7

What physical explanation can parapsychology offer?

1:21.0

Because one thing is describing phenomena.

1:24.1

Another one is explaining it in a physical framework.

1:28.3

Okay, so the answer is, I'm interpreting what Juliano says here in terms of is there an overall physical theory that explains parapsychological phenomena?

1:48.8

And because there are other theories, some of which involve physical matters that apply to aspects of parapsychology.

2:00.9

Like, for example, there have been studies done of the brainwaves of individuals talking to spirits,

2:10.0

and they're distinct from the brainwaves that are displayed in other situations.

2:19.3

So, for example, they'll have people who are skilled in talking to spirits,

2:23.3

and they'll say, okay, talk to a spirit now and we'll watch your brainwaves.

2:28.0

But then they'll say, okay, with same person, they'll say, okay, have a conversation with this living person and see, is it, is, are the brain waves similar or different?

2:43.8

And they're different.

...

Transcript will be available on the free plan in 6 days. Upgrade to see the full transcript now.

Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Catholic Answers, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.

Generated transcripts are the property of Catholic Answers and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.

Copyright © Tapesearch 2025.