Try royal opera house stream this Christmas for just one pound and watch enchanting productions including the nutcracker

enjoy unlimited access to over 80 extraordinary ballets, operas and exclusive behind-the-scenes features.

Sign up for Royal Opera House Stream now with your first month for just one pound.

For details, visit R.OH.org. UK forward slash offer.

One pound for the first month after 14 free days,

and nine 99 a month thereafter.

Cancel any time Ties and sees apply.

Attention all passengers. You can now book your train tickets on Uber and get 10% back in Uber credits to spend on your next train journey.

So no excuses not to visit your in-laws this Christmas.

Trains now on Uber T's and C's apply check the Uber app.

Welcome to the Times. To find out more, head to the Times.

To find out more, head to the Times.co. UK.

Welcome to the latest edition of the Times Opinion Podcast. My name is Tim Montgomery and

I'm joined today by two times columnist Alice Thompson and Libby Purvis and by

a political correspondent Laura Patel.

And here are our three topics for this week.

There's a generational difference over the Paris massacres.

The young bought up being Hanukkah candles and nativity plays and going on school trips to mosques. massacres. insensitive for them. The old generation of 60s students, the Charlie Hebedo

cartoonists, will always defend the right to offend. As 3 million copies of the

magazine hit the world's newsstands with a profit on the cover again, which

generation is right?

Ed Miliband did nothing wrong by vowing to weaponize the NHS.

...