4.6 • 4.5K Ratings
🗓️ 27 December 2024
⏱️ 76 minutes
🧾️ Download transcript
Watch our Thursday Throwdown: Aaron Maté Silences Piers Morgan Panel with Facts on Syria & Palestine https://www.usefulidiotspodcast.com/p/aaron-mate-silences-piers-morgan?r=je5va&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=false
For $6 a month, become a Useful Idiot! Get extended interviews, Thursday Throwdowns, and bonus content at http://usefulidiotspodcast.com
Join us LIVE on Youtube every Monday at 10am EST for Monday Mourning, where we watch the Sunday morning news shows so that you don't have to.
If you want to experience smoother digestion, a boost of energy, and an overall healthier body go to http://roundhouseprovisions.com/USEFUL for up to 44% off your regular-priced order plus a 90-day, money-back guarantee!
Support local jobs and get variety of high-quality clothing and activewear at https://www.american-giant.com and get 20% off your first order with promo code USEFUL. Thanks to American Giant for sponsoring the show!
“I think the reasonable conclusion is that Gaza is no more. There's nothing left in Gaza.”
Monday the 7th marked one full year of genocide in Gaza, the darkest era of a decades-long occupation by Israel, which has now begun to spread into the broader Middle East region.
This week we’re joined by Gaza expert and Useful Idiots fan-favorite Norman Finkelstein to look back on this genocidal year.
Norm points out that this is not, as Western and Israeli media claims, an “Israel-Hamas war.” This is not war. This is genocide. And Israel is not targeting Hamas; they are killing civilians, destroying civilian infrastructure, and picking off journalists, health workers, and children.
“I read this letter,” he tells us, “from sixty-five physicians from around the world who gave testimony as to what they observed. And every one of the physicians testified that the children who were coming into the hospital had bullet wounds to the skull or to the chest. No shrapnel. It wasn't bombs and shrapnel. It was targeted bullet wounds to the skull and to the chest of children. What does that have to do with war?”
“There were fifty-four disabled children who used the school in the convent complex. They fired two shells at it. What does that have to do with war?”
Norman also recalls meeting Hezbollah members, and shares what he got wrong about the organization. “Israel, he says, “is willing to kill for material benefit, and Hezbollah and Hamas are willing to die for survival” He also recounts his time meeting Hamas leaders, and explains Israel’s unfair advantage:
“Israel is the entrenched, concentrated manifestation of Western imperialism. It's got deep roots. It's got the whole Western system behind it, that Western system which won't let go. It will nuke China before it lets go of its global dominance. And in order to defeat it, it requires a very long-term struggle and intense calculation.”
Subscribe for the full interview where Norman explains this despair, and the generational hopelessness which lacks historical precedent.
“Our generation,” he laments, “has, for good reason, lost the belief, the conviction that we have the force of history behind us. That we have the force of justice behind us. Our generation believes there's a good chance we'll be defeated. There's a good chance we're not going to win.”
But that doesn’t mean we should give up.
“The only thing I can say as a conclusion is you never know. You can only know one thing for certain: If you do nothing, it can only get worse.”
It’s that certainty that he says keeps him going. “If you resist, there are moments where it looks very grim. And then there's that folk song, it's always darkest before the dawn. It's this hope that keeps me carrying on. It's always darkest before the dawn.”
“There's another reality. There's something in the human constitution that simply can't do nothing. In the face of such death and devastation, you just can't.”
Click on a timestamp to play from that location
0:00.0 | We are so excited to be joined by political scientist Norman Finkelstein, who is a prolific writer and the author of several books, including the Holocaust industry and Gaza and inquest into its martyrdom. |
0:12.3 | And this is a very sobering interview with Norman, not just because we're in a really bleak time. But because Norman offers some really frank words for the state of the resistance. |
0:27.6 | You know, there was a lot of hope that perhaps Israel would suffer a major strategic defeat. |
0:33.6 | A lot of people really believe that it would after it went into Gaza. But Norman, after so many years of studying this conflict, has a different take and has a really sobering assessment of what this current moment means for the Palestinian cause, especially in the aftermath of the killing of Hassan Nasrallah, of Hezbollah. |
0:55.3 | Now, he also makes clear that he's not judging anyone. |
1:00.1 | He's not offering any sort of sanctimonious point of view on any decisions by these various |
1:07.1 | resistance groups because it's very easy to judge when you're not living under |
1:11.3 | occupation, when you're not up against this genocidal government that Israel is. But it is important |
1:17.0 | to be as clear out as we can and to recognize, as Norman talks about this interview where |
1:21.9 | maybe he got some things wrong. And I think this is a really enlightening and formative interview |
1:26.9 | was always from a useful |
1:28.8 | idiot's fan favorite, someone who Katie, both you and I learned a lot from. |
1:32.9 | So let's hear from Norman Pickleston. |
1:40.8 | Norman, thanks so much for joining us. |
1:42.8 | Well, thank you for having me. |
1:46.5 | It's always my pleasure to be on with K.D. and Aaron. |
1:51.1 | We're recording this in the one-year anniversary week of October 7th. So let me just start with a general question. |
1:53.5 | You know, your overall assessment of where things are right now. |
1:56.7 | I have to enter a caveat before I even begin, which is right now the center of gravity has moved to the battlefield. |
2:06.6 | And I'm not a military expert, so it's very hard for me to assess the current situation. |
2:16.6 | At the political level, it's been surprisingly quiescent. I can't remember |
2:24.6 | a single instance where the Security Council has been so silent, or not so silent, has been totally silent. |
... |
Transcript will be available on the free plan in -91 days. Upgrade to see the full transcript now.
Disclaimer: The podcast and artwork embedded on this page are from Useful Idiots, LLC, and are the property of its owner and not affiliated with or endorsed by Tapesearch.
Generated transcripts are the property of Useful Idiots, LLC and are distributed freely under the Fair Use doctrine. Transcripts generated by Tapesearch are not guaranteed to be accurate.
Copyright © Tapesearch 2025.