Previously on Bear Brook Season 2, a true crime story.

You told us that Jason had admitted moving the car and was involved somewhat.

The truth, the ask of the truth, I have not seen a breaking point in you.

If you put a knife, if you put a knife in that woman, I want to know.

He stood up and he just said it was a bunch of bull crap and that anything that he had said wasn't true.

It's November 27, 1989, the Monday after Thanksgiving.

Tony Puff lands at the airport in Manchester, New Hampshire.

Tony walks off the plane and then waves hello to Detective Roland Lammy

and the other officers who are waiting for him.

Tony has no idea that just two days ago on Saturday,

Jason Carroll confessed on tape to murdering Sharon Johnson.

And Tony has no idea that while he was in the air, police taped a second confession from Jason.

Right from the top again, Jason.

When were you first contacted?

July 27th, 1988.

To do what?

Kill Sharon Johnson.

By whom?

Tony Puff.

And Tony has no idea that on both of those tapes,

Jason says Tony is guilty too.

When Tony got on a plane in North Carolina that morning, he thought he was coming to team up with detectives again, just like he had several months earlier when he wore a wire and tried to get Ken Johnson to admit to the murder.

...