In February of 2017, two teenage girls were killed in Delphi, Indiana.

On February 13th of that year, a day before Valentine's Day, 14-year-old Liberty Libby German and 13-year-old Abigail Abby Williams were out hiking on a

historic trailhead near downtown Delphi.

They would post a couple of pictures to Snapchat before disappearing that afternoon, and

an extensive search of the region would find their bodies the following day.

Both had been violently killed,

their throats slashed with a knife, and they were left near Deer Creek. But before their

death, Libby had managed to record video and audio of the man that had likely killed them,

who reportedly approached them on a high bridge and demanded they go with him, down the hill,

at gunpoint.

This individual was later dubbed bridge guy by authorities and the internet, and the footage

obtained of him, grainy as it was, was used to develop a composite image that has been

circulating ever since.

Despite what seemed like incredibly strong evidence, the investigation into this tragic double murder quickly

stagnated, beginning a multi-year process of authorities probing local deviants and offenders

in a quest to identify Bridge Guy.

For a time, investigators even began floating a second composite image of a much younger

man they believed might have been the killer, which came out just a short time before I released my original episode on this story back in 2019. Finally, in 2022, police

announced that they had identified a suspect in the crime. Then 50-year-old Richard Allen,

a Delphine native that had surprisingly come forward to police very early on. In the days immediately

following the murder of Abbey and Libby, Allen identified himself as someone that had been on the

same historic hiking trails the same day as the crime itself, and even claimed to be wearing

...