Previously on Bear Brook Season 2, a true crime story.

Right from the top again, Jason.

When were you first contacted?

July 27th, 1988.

You do what?

Kill Sharon Johnson.

By whom? Tony Puff.

I want you to explain to the jury, if you will, and I know it's very difficult to do this,

but I must ask you, how does Tony Pup feel about having participated in a murder Sharon Johnson.

I feel bad, and I'm sorry it took place.

I wish it would never even happen.

Karen basically said to me,

all kinds of promises have been made to him,

and I trust Roland Lammy explicitly,

and we got into kind of a heated discussion.

I never doubted for a minute that she was made promises.

Lammy made promises to her that he could never possibly keep. By the year 1991

by the year 1991, the state of New Hampshire had their story of who killed Sharon Johnson.

They had arrested three people and charged them all with capital murder.

Ken Johnson, Tony Puth, and Jason Carroll waited in separate jails for their day in court.

None of them could afford to pay for their own attorney, so the court assigned them each

a different team of lawyers.

...