It's an inexplicable story and I don't even know how I became a part of it.

It would be unfathomable that I would be able to predict how this case would come together.

But I'm saying 20 years later, I can't tell you the motive for this.

I'm Scott Weinberger, investigative journalist and former deputy sheriff.

I'm Anna Sige-Nikolazi, former New York City homicide prosecutor and host of investigation

discoveries to conviction.

And this is anatomy of murder.

I don't normally say this, but this is a case that I look at as one for the record books.

I mean, there is a twist in this case that, you know, when you think you've seen it all,

I don't think anyone could have seen this one coming and I'm really excited for covering

this today.

It's like a John Grisham novel and tell me if you think I'm right or wrong by the time

we're finished.

I already think you're right.

I like that.

I'll take it.

I'll take that.

So for this one, I spoke with then District Attorney who was also the prosecutor in the

case, John Tyson, who is now a judge in Wisconsin where this took place.

Chippewa Falls is a small town, a friendly town as a prosecutor.

It's a place that you can't go to the grocery store after work because when you're picking

up one or two items, it's going to take you about a half hour because all the people

...