I picked up the phone and I said, I'm a prosecutor from Chipotle, Flauts, Wisconsin.

I'm going to tell you some information.

You're going to tell me I'm wrong.

I'm going to say thank you and we're never going to talk again.

Emotionally I think my heart drops out of the floor.

The connections were just too good.

I'm Scott Weinberger, investigative journalist and former deputy sheriff.

I'm Anna Sige-Nikolasi, former New York City homicide prosecutor and host of investigation

discoveries through conviction.

And this is Anatomy of Murk.

Last week we covered the story of Mary Jane Markhart.

Looking forward to getting back into this one.

You're right, Anna Sige-Nikolasi.

But it's got so many great twists and turns.

We really believe it takes two full episodes to tell this story.

Let's go back to March of 2000, March 13 to be exact.

Just after four o'clock in the afternoon, Alfred Markhart walked into his home, into his

garage, and found his wife Mary Jane.

Unresponsive, Mary Jane was shot and stabbed.

Their son Bill Markhart was not living at the home, had not been seen for a while before

the homicide, and actually days later they still weren't able to determine his location.

They realize that he's not just missing, but he's their prime suspect.

...